Mrs. Garrett's Butter Tarts

$4.95

Free Shipping on All $50+ Orders

131 reviews
We’ve partnered with Mrs. Garrett’s Bake Shop, a small bakery out in Inverary, Ontario, known for its authentic take on this Canadian delicacy.
Option: 2-Pack
visa master american express paypal apple pay
Small batches made in perth, on
FAST, EASY SHIPPING ACROSS CANADA
AWARD-WINNING CUSTOMER SERVICE

We’ve partnered with Mrs. Garrett’s Bake Shop, a small bakery out in Inverary, Ontario, known for its authentic take on this Canadian delicacy.

What started as a small order of 500 butter tarts as a tasty treat to accompany our Ontario Butter Tart Moonshine has now grown to an order of 15,000 Ontario-local butter tarts.This 37-year-old Ontario bakery has withstood the test of time, with core 3 members of their small but mighty team who have been there since its inception.

When you place an order from the Top Shelf Distillers online store you will be able to choose from different “shipping methods” at checkout. These include Local Delivery, Shipping, and Free Pickup

Local Delivery orders take 12-24 hours to process unless otherwise stated on specific product listings.

Shipping orders take 12-24 hours to process unless otherwise stated.

Pick Up orders take 2-24 hours to be ready for pick up unless otherwise stated on specific product listings.

Your order may be delayed if you have a pre-order product in your order (stipulated on the product page). If there is a delay with your order for another reason, we will reach out to the email provided at checkout.

Any orders placed on a holiday or weekend will be processed the next business day. In the unlikely situation we cannot deliver in time, we will contact you to arrange an alternative delivery.

*By ordering with our online system, you are confirming that you are of legal drinking age. Top Shelf Distillers, our carriers, and pickup locations reserves the right to ask for identification upon delivery to confirm age.*

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 131 Reviews
5 ★
95% 
124
4 ★
4% 
5
3 ★
1% 
2
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • butter tarts
  • order
  • Filling
  • pastry
  • Tarts
  • crust
  • Moonshine
  • flavour
  • best
  • Everyone
28 August 2023
GW
Glenda W.
Canada Canada

Great butter tarts

I don’t know who Mrs Garrett is but she is a good baker and these butter tarts are delicious

28 August 2023
TL
Terri L.
Canada Canada

Butter tarts

The butter tarts are delicious. They freeze well so I got quite a few of them,

27 August 2023
RS
Robert S.
Canada Canada

Amazing

I loved them…They tasted great…I always look forward to them

19 August 2023
KB
Kathy B.
Canada Canada

Yummy 3

Best I have ever had

15 August 2023
DS
David S.
Canada Canada

Mrs Garrett’s Butter Tarts

They are the best I have ever had. Need some raisins, but otherwise they are the best.

07 August 2023
JF
Jason F.
Canada Canada

Delicious!!!

I was leary about ordering butter tarts through the mail, but they survived the shipping process and were absolutely delicious!! I will definitely be ordering them again.

04 August 2023
A
Anonymous
Canada Canada

Ooey Gooey Goodness!

I tried to resist the butter tarts that came with my order... but I failed! I am so glad I did! They were absolutely delicious... BETTER than Grandma used to make! Sweet - but not too sweet, creamy smooth filling and flaky, buttery pastry! Oh my!!!! Can't wait to try them again :)

04 August 2023
WR
Wallace R.
Canada Canada

Review

Very good like your product

03 August 2023
A
Anonymous
Canada Canada

Tarts

Taste great

28 July 2023
DG
Donald G. Witzel
Canada Canada

To Die For!

Absolutely to die for - abandon the calorie counting… these are nothing but delicious!!

22 July 2023
A
Anonymous
Canada Canada

Butter Tarts

The butter tarts are wonderful!

06 July 2023
CM
Cindy M.
Canada Canada

Love Mrs. Garrett whoever she is!? lol

Loved the taste & the texture too as the pastry was both flaky & delicious!

23 June 2023
A
Anonymous
Canada Canada

Mrs Garrett's butter tarts

The tarts are near perfect for my liking, interior soft but not runny, crunchy, caramel bubble over on the crust, yum, yum. I like a thinner crust personally but this crust is the next best thing.

13 June 2023
CM
Cindy M.
Canada Canada

Love Mrs. Garrett whoever she is!? lol

Deliciously sweet satisfies my sweet tooth & the pastry is so flaky too!

19 May 2023
A
Anonymous
Canada Canada

Butter Tarts to Die For

The butter tarts are absolutely amazing!

12 May 2023
LN
Lori N.
Canada Canada

Excellent!

The butter tarts are exceptional!