Mrs. Garrett's Butter Tarts

$4.95 $4.25

Free Shipping on All $50+ Orders

91 reviews
We’ve partnered with Mrs. Garrett’s Bake Shop, a small bakery out in Inverary, Ontario, known for its authentic take on this Canadian delicacy.
Option: 2-Pack
visa master american express paypal apple pay
Small batches made in perth, on

We’ve partnered with Mrs. Garrett’s Bake Shop, a small bakery out in Inverary, Ontario, known for its authentic take on this Canadian delicacy.

What started as a small order of 500 butter tarts as a tasty treat to accompany our Ontario Butter Tart Moonshine has now grown to an order of 15,000 Ontario-local butter tarts.This 37-year-old Ontario bakery has withstood the test of time, with core 3 members of their small but mighty team who have been there since its inception.

When you place an order from the Top Shelf Distillers online store you will be able to choose from different “shipping methods” at checkout. These include Local Delivery, Shipping, and Free Pickup

Local Delivery orders take 12-24 hours to process unless otherwise stated on specific product listings.

Shipping orders take 12-24 hours to process unless otherwise stated.

Pick Up orders take 2-24 hours to be ready for pick up unless otherwise stated on specific product listings.

Your order may be delayed if you have a pre-order product in your order (stipulated on the product page). If there is a delay with your order for another reason, we will reach out to the email provided at checkout.

Any orders placed on a holiday or weekend will be processed the next business day. In the unlikely situation we cannot deliver in time, we will contact you to arrange an alternative delivery.

*By ordering with our online system, you are confirming that you are of legal drinking age. Top Shelf Distillers, our carriers, and pickup locations reserves the right to ask for identification upon delivery to confirm age.*

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 91 Reviews
5 ★
4 ★
3 ★
2 ★
1 ★
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • butter tarts
  • order
  • Tarts
  • Filling
  • pastry
  • crust
  • Everyone
  • Moonshine
  • flavour
  • delivery
27 January 2023
Suzanne G.
Canada Canada

Heavenly good

Delicious butter tarts - didn’t last long Treat yourself to these decadent, buttery, flakey goodies. I always order with my favourite TopShelf beverage.

19 January 2023
Karl B.
Canada Canada

Top notch

These butter tarts are second to none, even shipping half way across the country, they were delicious! Will be ordering more soon...

19 January 2023
Canada Canada


19 January 2023
Canada Canada

Buttertarts yummm

Best buttertarts I have ever tasted. Pure heaven with each bite!

19 January 2023
Angela C.
Canada Canada

Mrs Garrett’s butter tarts

Love them! I want more!

19 January 2023
Canada Canada

Delicious butter tarts

Having purchased these in the store a few months back, we decide to include a few more in a recent online purchase from Top Shelf. Never a disappointment when we eat these delicious butter tarts. Looking forward to getting more, if not from Top Shelf, elsewhere in the region.

11 January 2023
clare s.

best I have ever had

filling is great and the dough so flakey

09 January 2023
Linda G.
Canada Canada

Fabulous Butter Tarts

The butter tarts were fantastic! Nice addition to the moonshine. Makes a great gift when combined with Butter Tart Moonshine!

08 January 2023
Todd G.
Canada Canada

Grandma Garret

These tarts were like the ones my Grandma made. Flakey pastry, sweet gooey filling. Only ordered two to try but will be ordering several cases. Also pairs well with the butter tart liquor.

07 January 2023
Christine P.
Canada Canada


Delicious pastry, delicious filling, they were gone in a flash! Will definitely order again.

31 December 2022
James N.
Canada Canada

It's an 8

Lots of flavour in the pie. Crust is dry. Give it an 8 Goes very well with the Butter Tart Moonshine

31 December 2022
Canada Canada

Mrs Garrett’s Butter Tarts

Delicious! I bought extra to fill out the order and so glad I did!

08 December 2022
Judy C.
Canada Canada

Butter Tarts

Have never tasted or enjoyed butter tarts like this before. Pastry is light and fresh. Absolutely full of flavour. The weight of the product will surprise

05 December 2022
Nick E.
Canada Canada

Best ever

These have got to be the best butter tart I’ve ever had!!!!

03 December 2022
Nikky S.
Canada Canada

The best I have ever had (sorry Grandma)

These are incredible. The balance of flavour. The depth of the pastry and consistency of the filling. The perfectly melt in your mouth tart ! Amazing. I will NEED to order these with each top shelf delivery we make. A great side when sipping the delicious Irish Cream Moonshine.

27 November 2022
Canada Canada


They were great!